Do Ice Cubes in the RV Black Tank Really Work?


I know I’m supposed to be working on the tank additive experiments now (and I am, I promise), but when I had the idea for this detour, I couldn’t resist.

 

I’m sure we’ve all heard that advice at one time or another to dump a bag of ice into the RV black tank to “scrub it out” or “knock things loose”.   On the surface, it makes sense. But does it really work? I had to find out.

Since I had the black tank simulator, and my old pickup truck, I put this advice to the test.  By the way, I love that truck – I’ve had it since 1987!  Anyway, I constructed a rig to hold the tank still in the truck while I drove around, and I put two cameras on it. I even got a camera INSIDE the tank to catch the action. I went with a purple simulated waste this time, using one of the new recipes based on a paper by NASA scientists. (Yes, they have scientists that develop simulated waste.) After that, it was buy some ice and drive around for an hour or so.

But did it work?

Short answer: Maybe kind of, but not really all that great.

I wanted to go all “Myth-Busters” on it and declare the old advice a hoax, but in the end, you can get a very limited scrubbing action with the ice cubes. But that comes with a few caveats.

1: You have to drive your RV like a demon

I drove my truck like a madman. Even with that, I was unsuccessful in getting the ice very far up the sides of the tank, or in completely knocking all the waste off. You WOULD NOT drive your RV like I was driving. Trust me. And even so, in the video, you’re just seeing the highlights. Most of the time, the ice just sat there.

2: You have to use the right amount of ice

If you put too much ice in the tank, it will kind of pack itself in, and not move at all. You want enough to cover the bottom, and then a little bit more than that. But the trouble is, most of us can’t see into the black tank to know how much that is.

3: You have to use the right amount of water

You want the ice moving, but not floating. If the ice is floating, well, it’s floating, and anything underneath the ice is just soaking.  If soaking is what you’re going to do, then even room temperature water is more effective than ice water.

4: Even if you do everything right, it’s pretty darn weak

Scrubbing works on abrasion, but ice and water is a very low-friction environment. The ice just doesn’t smack into things very hard. Most of the time, the stuck on waste was pushing the ice, and not the other way around. Now, you might be able to improve on that by freezing up a solid block of ice that you can get down the toilet. But by the time you’re making special three pound ice cubes that you can fit down your RV toilet… well I’m just going to say you’re going too far.

By now, I’ve seen enough of these experiments to know that most of the cleaning action you saw was just due to the water, and not the ice. In fact, if you really had some stuff baked on in there, you’d be better off going the other way, and pouring HOT water down the tank.  Think about it: you’ve never seen anyone try to clean a casserole dish by putting ice cubes in it, because everyone knows it won’t work.  This is no different.

So what’s my take?

If you need to clean stuck on material out your black tank, and you don’t have an in-tank rinsing system – save your money, save your ice, and save your gas.  Just soak it.  It will work just as well.

Enjoy the video.  This one is only 8 minutes long!!  (And Stef’s in it, so it’s prettier than my usual videos.)



James is a former rocket scientist, a USA Cycling certified coach, and lifelong fitness buff. When he's not driving the RV, or modifying the RV (or - that one time - doing both at once), you can find him racing bicycles, or building furniture, or making music. In his spare time, he works for a large IT company.


    17 thoughts on “Do Ice Cubes in the RV Black Tank Really Work?

      1. Stefany

        Hi George! It’s actually an original! James is a musician, and he and his buddy Kyle recorded it in our basement music studio! Kyle is an amazing guitarist….James did drums and bass. Pretty much any music you hear on any of our videos was James’ own stuff, unless the YouTube blurb states otherwise. I’m sure he’s thrilled for the compliment!!!

        Reply
      1. Frank Llamas

        I enjoyed the ice cube video. I also heard the same thing works using dishwasher liquid soap. let me know if you ever try that test. I’ll be checking out your other stuff. thanks.

        Reply
        1. James - Post author

          I do plan to eventually test tank additives. As soon as I finish, and can move the woodworking project out of my shop, I’ll be back on that. The GEO method (dish soap and water softener) is on the list for testing.
          Cheers!

    1. Tom Boles

      Hi James,

      Great look at an old RV’ing myth!

      Just for fun, I’d like to take isseu with this statement:

      “you’ve never seen anyone try to clean a casserole dish by putting ice cubes in it, because everyone knows it won’t work.”

      No, but people DO use solid CO2 “ice” to clean rocket parts:
      http://www.coldjet.com/en/industries/aerospace.php

      The whole idea:
      http://www.coldjet.com/en/information/what-is-dry-ice-blasting.php

      I was using liquid CO2 for accelerated cooling in temperature cycling chambers over 35 years ago and that is when I learned about CO2 bead blasting, a very cool cleaning technology that I did not need…

      I’m not advocating the use of solid CO2 of course, since I am in the “Who Cares?’ camp when it comes to cleaning my black and grey tanks. I just wanted to bring up a counterpoint to your “ices cubes in the casserole dish”

      If anyone is really concerned about getting accurate readings on tank level, then a through-the-tank sensor system is really the only reasonable way to go. No electrodes to get mucked up and so nothing to clean.

      Thanks again for the great work and documnentation on some of the myths in the Dark Side of RVing!

      Reply
      1. James - Post author

        Hey Tom! The dry ice blasting sounds interesting. I want one.
        I have no idea what I’d do with it, but a dry ice blasting gun just seems like an awesome thing to have.

        And I completely agree with you on the tank sensors. I put them on Das Bus. I don’t know why manufacturers even bother with the probes anymore.

        Reply
    2. nivram

      OK my observation, small tank, it should have been bigger,not enough room for the ice to really get moving, close to the size of a regular holding tank. Next, the ice that was purchased was ROUND, and did a lot of ROLLING, and no scraping as ice cubes would have thus not doing the job. Good theory, but inconclusive as far a results is concerned.

      my pennie’s worth.

      Reply
      1. James - Post author

        Nivram,
        Actually, the clear holding tank is approximately the same dimensions as the tank in my class B – it’s only a few inches smaller in width. The additional speed that ice might pick up in that couple inches would be more than negated by the fact that nobody would actually drive their RV the way I was driving that truck. The lateral, longitudinal, and sometimes even vertical acceleration I was putting on that tank is far greater than anything you’d ever get with a real RV. That ice was moving more and faster than anything in anyone’s actual RV tank, ever.

        As to the square vs. round ice cubes… Uh… really? I’m watching slow-motion video of the ice right now, and it is tumbling and sliding. There may be some rolling, but it’s completely at random. For something to “roll” there needs to be enough friction on one surface to cause the rolling. There’s just not enough friction between ice and water (or between ice and the film of water on a piece of waste) to consistently cause anything to roll. And even if you don’t believe that, the ice cubes were cylindrical and not spheres (at least, the ones that weren’t broken), meaning they all had at least some edges.

        I don’t think either of the things you mentioned would have changed the results of the experiment. You are, of course, free to continue to put ice down your tank, if you really believe in it. If you were able to get some razor-sharp square ice cubes, and get them REALLY moving – say, from a musket blast, then you might be on to something. I’d be happy to help you test that theory, but we’ll have to use your rig. 😉

        Reply
    3. Kip

      Keep up the good work.

      Interesting that you actually went to (all the trouble) to prove this idea is a waste of time.

      I always thought ice was just too wimpy to do much in a RV tank.
      Your truck bed test is a (great idea) and that truck certainly is more choppy than any RV suspension I am aware of.

      You have put another MYTH down the toilet!

      Reply
      1. James - Post author

        Thanks Kip. What drew me to this experiment was the thought of tearing around town with cameras rolling on a clear tank of simulated waste and ice in the back of the truck. It was too ridiculous to pass up!

        Reply
    4. Mark Freeman

      Not that I wanted you to get pulled over, but can imagine the dialogue with the officer if you had been pulled over?

      Reply

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Comment moderation is in use. Please do not submit your comment twice -- it will appear once we have had the chance to review it.